Fixed fee vs percentage: which costs you less?
Enter your average sale and card mix to compare a pricing plan that charges a percentage plus a fixed fee on every transaction with a flat percentage and no fixed fee. Every rate is editable, so you can put in your own provider’s figures.
1. Your business
Card mix (% of card sales)
2. Plan A: percentage + fixed fee
Example figures: around 0.35% + 3c is common for domestic debit in Ireland. Replace them with the rates on your own statement.
3. Plan B: flat percentage, no fixed fee
Pre-filled with Shift4 Dine for cafés card rates: 0.8% on EEA consumer cards, 1.99% on commercial and non-EEA cards. The €39/month POS subscription isn’t included, because it covers the till system rather than card processing. Add it under monthly fees if you want a like-for-like total.
Monthly card turnover
—
Plan A per month
—
Plan B per month
—
—
Cost per sale at different sale values
| Sale | Plan A | Plan B |
|---|
Per-sale costs use your card mix and exclude monthly fees.
Want the real numbers?
Your statement has more lines than any calculator can cover. Send it to us and we’ll work out your actual costs and what you’d pay elsewhere, free.
Free statement review →This calculator gives an estimate for comparison only. It doesn’t include every charge that can appear on a statement, such as authorisation fees, card-not-present surcharges, chargebacks, terminal rental or minimum monthly charges. Your actual costs depend on your agreement.
Why the fixed fee matters so much
A fixed fee is the same whether the customer spends €3 or €300. On a large sale it hardly registers, but on a small sale it can cost more than the percentage does. That’s why businesses with lots of low-value sales, like cafés, bakeries and convenience stores, often pay more than their headline rate suggests.
The break-even sale value in the results is the point where both plans cost the same. Below it, the plan with no fixed fee is cheaper. Above it, the plan with the lower percentage wins.
PCI fees explained
The monthly fee, and the non-compliance fee that catches people out.
Minimum Monthly Service Charge
How the MMSC floor works and who it affects.
Commercial card rates
Why business cards cost more to accept.
Blended vs IC++ pricing
Which pricing model suits your business.
IC++ fee calculator
Model AIBMS Interchange++ pricing by card type and region.
How card fees work
Our full guide to the fee stack.
Shift4 Dine for cafés
€39/month POS with no fixed fee per sale.
Get an exact comparison
Send us a recent statement and we’ll compare your actual costs against the providers we work with.